Asian Nursing Research
Volume 3, Issue 2 , Pages 49-62, June 2009

Measuring Anxiety in Children: A Methodological Review of the Literature

  • Hae-Ra Han, RN, PhD

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationCorrespondence to: Hae-Ra Han, RN, PhD, The Johns Hopkins University, School of Nursing, 525 N. Wolfe St., Baltimore, MD 21205-2110, USA

Johns Hopkins University School of Nursing, Baltimore, MD, USA

Received 23 February 2009; received in revised form 17 March 2009; accepted 27 April 2009.

Article Outline

This paper provides a comprehensive methodological review of the literature concerning anxiety measurement in children. Initially, a conceptual basis for anxiety measures is introduced, followed by specific approaches to measuring childhood anxiety based on 14 original articles. In particular, a variety of strategies that have been used in previous research are discussed in detail with theoretical underpinnings. Common approaches to measure anxiety such as self-reported instruments, observational ratings, and behavioral checklists are reviewed one by one with a critical look at the strengths and weaknesses of each of these approaches. While multiple measures of anxiety are available to assess the level of anxiety in children, selection of measurement approach should be an iterative process based on rigorous evaluation of evidence of reliability and cross-validation of the tool across different age groups of children.

Key Words:  anxiety , child , epidemiologic measurement

No full text is available. To read the body of this article, please view the PDF online.

 

Back to Article Outline

References 

  1. *Indicates studies measuring anxiety in children that were included in the review.
  2. * Achenbach TM . Manual for the child behavior checklist/4–18 and 1991 profile . Burlington, VT: University of Vermont, Department of Psychiatry; 1991;
  3. Akçakaya N , Aydogan M , Hassanzadeh A , Camcioglu Y , Cokugraş H . Psychological problems in Turkish asthmatic children and their families . Allergologia et immunopathologia . 2003;31:282–287
  4. American Psychiatric Association  . In: Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM-IV . 4th ed.. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 2000;p. 429–484
  5. Anderson ER , Hope DA . The relationship among social phobia, objective and perceived physiological reactivity, and anxiety sensitivity in an adolescent population . Journal of Anxiety Disorder . 2009;23:18–26
  6. * Behar LB . The Preschool Behavior Questionnaire . Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology . 1977;5:256–275
  7. Benton TD , Ifeagwu JA , Smith-Whitley K . Anxiety and depression in children and adolescents with sickle cell disease . Current Psychiatry Reports . 2007;9:114–121
  8. Blumberg SH , Izard CE . Discriminating patterns of emotions in 10-and 11-year-old children's anxiety and depression . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology . 1986;51:852–857
  9. Bourne EJ . In: The anxiety and phobia workbook . 4th ed.. Oakland, CA: New Harbinger Publications; 2006;p. 4–29
  10. * Brandt K , Fenz WD . Specificity in verbal and physiological indicants of anxiety . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1969;29:663–675
  11. Castaneda A , McCandless BR , Palermo DS . The children's form of the manifest anxiety scale . Child Development . 1956;27:317–326
  12. Cattell RB . Comments on Drs. Lazarus and Averill's paper . In:  Spielberger CD editors. Anxiety: Current trends in theory and research . New York: Academic Press; 1972;p. 285–290
  13. Cattell RB , Scheier IH . The nature of anxiety: A review of thirteen multivariate analyses comprising 814 variables . Psychological Reports . 1958;4:351–388
  14. * Chorpita BF , Tracey SA , Brown TA , Collica TJ , Barlow DH . Assessment of worry in children of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire . Behavior Research and Therapy . 1997;35:569–581
  15. Claar RL , Baber KF , Simons LE , Logan DE , Walker LS . Pain coping profiles in adolescents with chronic pain . Pain . 2008;140:368–375
  16. * Clatworthy S , Simon K , Tiedeman ME . Child drawing: Hospital – an instrument designed to measure the emotional status of hospitalized school-aged children . Journal of Pediatric Nursing . 1999;14:2–9
  17. Codori A , Petersen GM , Boyd PA , Brandt J , Giardiello FM . Genetic testing for cancer in children: Short-term psychological effect . Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine . 1996;150:1131–1138
  18. Compas BE , Worsham NL , Epping-Jordan JE , Grant KE , Mireault G , Howell DC , et al.   When mom or dad has cancer: Markers of psychological distress in cancer patients, spouses, and children . Health Psychology . 1994;13:507–515
  19. Conklin HM , Li C , Xiong X , Ogg RJ , Merchant TE . Predicting change in academic abilities after conformal radiation therapy for localized ependymoma . Journal of Clinical Oncology . 2008;26:3965–3970
  20. * Endler NS , Hunt JM , Rosenstein AJ . An S-R inventory of anxiousness . Psychological Monographs . 1962;536:1–33
  21. Fenz WD . Specificity in somatic responses to anxiety . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1967;24:1183–1190
  22. * Fenz WD , Epstein S . Manifest anxiety: Unifactorial or multifactorial composition . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1965;20:773–780
  23. Finch AJ , Kendall PC , Dannenburg MA , Morgan JR . Effects of task difficulty on state-trait anxiety in emotionally disturbed children . Journal of Genetic Psychology . 1978;133:253–259
  24. Freud S . The problem of anxiety . New York: Norton; 1936;
  25. Gerlach AL , Mourlane D , Rist F . Public and private heart rate feedback in social phobia: A manipulation of anxiety visibility . Cognitive Behaviour Therapy . 2004;33:36–45
  26. Hazzard A , Webb C , Kleemeier C , Angert L , Pohl J . Child sexual abuse prevention: Evaluation and one-year follow-up . Child Abuse & Neglect . 1991;15:123–138
  27. Heiney SP , Bryant LH , Walker S , Parrish RS , Provenzano FJ , Kelly KE . Impact of parental anxiety on child emotional adjustment when a parent has cancer . Oncology Nursing Forum . 1997;24:655–661
  28. Izard CE . Comments on Drs. Phillips, Martin, and Meyers' paper . In:  Spielberger CD editors. Anxiety: Current trends in theory and research . New York: Academic Press; 1972;p. 465–468
  29. Joiner TE , Schmidt KL , Schmidt NB . Low-end specificity of childhood measures of emotional distress: Differential effects for depression and anxiety . Journal of Personality Assessment . 1996;67:258–271
  30. * Joshi RT . Field-dependence, anxiety, and personality . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1974;38:1328
  31. Kantaputra PN , Chiewcharnvalijkit K , Wairatpanich K , Malikaew P , Aramrattana A . Children's attitudes toward behavior management techniques used by dentists . Journal of Dentistry for Children . 2007;74:4–9
  32. * Kaufman AS , Eller BF , Applegate B . An investigation of somatic anxiety and intelligence in children using the Kaufman-ABC and an APPLE Iie program measuring heart rate . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1990;70:387–394
  33. Kim DY , Rah YC , Kim DW , Kim SW , Han DH , Kong IG , et al.   Impact of tonsillectomy on pediatric psychological status . International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology . 2008;72:1359–1363
  34. Kleinman MJ , Russ SW . Primary process thinking and anxiety in children . Journal of Personality . 1988;52:254–262
  35. Kovacs M . Rating scales to assess depression in preschool children . Acta Paedopsychiatry . 1981;46:305–315
  36. Lähteenmäki PM , Sjöblom J , Korhonen T , Salmi TT . The life situation of parents over the first year after their child's cancer diagnosis . Acta Paediatrica . 2004;93:1654–1660
  37. Lazarus RS , Averill JR . Emotion and cognition: with special reference to anxiety . In:  Spielberger CD editors. Anxiety: Current trends in theory and research . New York: Academic Press; 1972;p. 241–283
  38. * Lore RK . Palmar sweating and transitory anxiety in children . Child Development . 1965;36:115–124
  39. Mackner LM , Crandall WV , Szigethy EM . Psychosocial functioning in pediatric inflammatory bowel disease . Inflammatory Bowel Diseases . 2006;12:239–244
  40. May R . The meaning of anxiety . New York: Ronald Press; 1950;
  41. Meyer TJ , Miller ML , Metzger RL , Borkovec TD . Development and validation of the Penn State Worry Questionnaire . Behavior Research and Therapy . 1990;28:487–495
  42. Mohammadi MR , Taylor E , Fombonne E . Prevalence of psychological problems amongst Iranian immigrant children and adolescents in UK . Iranian Journal of Psychiatry . 2006;1:12–18
  43. Moore JB , Mosher RB . Adjustment responses of children and their mothers to cancer: Self-care and anxiety . Oncology Nursing Forum . 1997;24:519–525
  44. Mullick MS , Nahar JS , Haq SA . Psychiatric morbidity, stressors, impact, and burden in juvenile idiopathic arthritis . Journal of Health, Population, and Nutrition . 2005;23:142–149
  45. Piaget J . The psychology of intelligence . London: Routledge; 1950;
  46. * Prytula RE , Hiland DN . Analysis of general anxiety scale for children and draw-a-person measures of general anxiety level of elementary school children . Perceptual and Motor Skills . 1975;41:995–1007
  47. * Rebesco M , Cotler S , Jason LA . The development and validation of a behavior rating scale for blood sampling with children . Heart & Lung . 1984;13:540–545
  48. Reynolds CR . Concurrent validity of What I think and feel: A revised measure of children's manifest anxiety . Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology . 1980;6:271–280
  49. * Reynolds CR , Richmond BO . What I think and feel: A revised measure of children's manifest anxiety . Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology . 1978;6:271–280
  50. Sands SA , Milner JS , Goldberg J , Mukhi V , Moliterno JA , Maxfield C , et al.   Quality of life and behavioral follow-up study of pediatric survivors of craniopharyngioma . Journal of Neurosurgery . 2005;103:302–311
  51. Schultz KA , Ness KK , Whitton J , Recklitis C , Zebrack B , Robison LL , et al.   Behavioral and social outcomes in adolescent survivors of childhood cancer: A report from the childhood cancer survivor study . Journal of Clinical Oncology . 2007;25:3649–3656
  52. Servitzoglou M , Papadatou D , Tsiantis I , Vasilatou-Kosmidis H . Psychosocial functioning of young adolescent and adult survivors of childhood cancer . Support Care in Cancer . 2008;16:29–36
  53. Sheskin RB , Klein H , Lowental U . Assessment of children's anxiety throughout dental treatment by their drawings . Journal of Dentistry for Children . 1982;49:99–106
  54. Sonnenberg E , Venham E . Human figure drawings as a measure of the child's response to dental visits . Journal of Dentistry for Children . 1977;44:438–442
  55. Spielberger CD . Theory and research on anxiety . In:  Spielberger CD editors. Anxiety and behavior . New York: Academic Press; 1966;p. 3–20
  56. Spielberger CD . Conceptual and methodological issues in anxiety research . In:  Spielberger CD editors. Anxiety: Current trends in theory and research . New York: Academic Press; 1972;p. 481–493
  57. * Spielberger CD . Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children . Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press; 1973;
  58. Stam H , Grootenhuis MA , Last BF . Social and emotional adjustment in young survivors of childhood cancer . Supportive Care in Cancer . 2001;9:489–513
  59. Stam H , Grootenhuis MA , Caron HN , Last BF . Quality of life and current coping in young adult survivors of childhood cancer: Positive expectations about the further course of the disease were correlated with better quality of life . Psychooncology . 2006;15:31–43
  60. Sullivan HS . The interpersonal theory of psychiatry . New York: Norton; 1953;
  61. van de Putte EM , Engelbert RH , Kuis W , Kimpen JL , Uiterwaal CS . Alexithymia in adolescents with chronic fatigue syndrome . Journal of Psychosomatic Research . 2007;63:377–380
  62. von Essen L , Enskär K , Kreuger A , Larsson B , Sjödén PO . Self-esteem, depression and anxiety among Swedish children and adolescents on and off cancer treatment . Acta Paediatrica . 2000;89:229–236
  63. Watson D , Kendall PC . Understanding anxiety and depression: Their relation to negative and positive affective states . In:  Kendall PC ,  Watson D editor. Anxiety and depression: Distinctive and overlapping features . San Diego, CA: Academic Press; 1989;p. 3–26
  64. Welch AS , Wadsworth ME , Compas BE . Adjustment of children and adolescents to parental cancer . Cancer . 1996;77:1409–1418
  65. Wesley, R. L. (1988). Social support and health outcomes associated with children with sickle cell disease. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Maryland, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
  66. Windsorova D , Stewart SM , Lovitt R , Waller DA , Andrews WS . Emotional adaptation in children after liver transplantation . Journal of Pediatrics . 1991;119:880–887
  67. Yeh CH , Wang YF . Competence of and emotional/behavioral problems in pediatric oncology patients in Taiwan . Cancer Nursing . 2004;27:413–422

PII: S1976-1317(09)60016-5

doi:10.1016/S1976-1317(09)60016-5

Asian Nursing Research
Volume 3, Issue 2 , Pages 49-62, June 2009

Article Tools