Asian Nursing Research
Volume 2, Issue 1 , Pages 17-24, March 2008

Common Factor Analysis Versus Principal Component Analysis: Choice for Symptom Cluster Research

  • Hee-Ju Kim, PhD, RN

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationCorrespondence to: Hee-Ju Kim, PhD, RN, Full-time Instructor, Department of Nursing, University Ulsan, Nan-gu Dea-Hak-Ro 102, Ulsan 680-749, Korea

Full-time Instructor, Department of Nursing, University of Ulsan, Ulsan, South Korea

Article Outline

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to examine differences between two factor analytical methods and their relevance for symptom cluster research: common factor analysis (CFA) versus principal component analysis (PCA).

Methods

Literature was critically reviewed to elucidate the differences between CFA and PCA. A secondary analysis (N = 84) was utilized to show the actual result differences from the two methods.

Results

CFA analyzes only the reliable common variance of data, while PCA analyzes all the variance of data. An underlying hypothetical process or construct is involved in CFA but not in PCA. PCA tends to increase factor loadings especially in a study with a small number of variables and/or low estimated communality. Thus, PCA is not appropriate for examining the structure of data.

Conclusion

If the study purpose is to explain correlations among variables and to examine the structure of the data (this is usual for most cases in symptom cluster research), CFA provides a more accurate result. If the purpose of a study is to summarize data with a smaller number of variables, PCA is the choice. PCA can also be used as an initial step in CFA because it provides information regarding the maximum number and nature of factors. In using factor analysis for symptom cluster research, several issues need to be considered, including subjectivity of solution, sample size, symptom selection, and level of measure.

Key Words:  cancer , nursing , statistics , symptom clusters

No full text is available. To read the body of this article, please view the PDF online.

 

Back to Article Outline

References 

  1. Barsevick AM , Whitmer K , Nail LM , Beck SL , Dudley WN . Symptom cluster research: Conceptual, design, measurement, and analysis issues . Journal of Pain and Symptom Management . 2006;31:85–95
  2. Cattell RB . The meaning and strategic use of factor analysis . In:  Nesselroade JR ,  Cattell RB editor. Handbook of multivariate experimental psychology . 2nd ed.. New York: Plenum Press; 1988;p. 131–201
  3. Chen ML , Tseng HC . Symptom clusters in cancer patients . Supportive Care in Cancer . 2006;14:825–830
  4. Dodd MJ , Miaskowski C , Paul SM . Symptom clusters and their effect on the functional status of patients with cancer . Oncology Nursing Forum . 2001;28:465–470
  5. Fabrigar LR , Wegener DT , MacCallum RC , Strahan EJ . Evaluating the use of exploratory factor analysis in psychological research . Psychological Methods . 1999;4:272–299
  6. Gift AU , Jablonski A , Stommel M , Given W . Symptom clusters in elderly patients with lung cancer . Oncology Nursing Forum . 2004;31:203–210
  7. Gorsuch RL . Factor analysis . 2nd ed.. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1983;
  8. Kim, H.-J., & Abraham, I. (in press). Statistical approaches to modeling symptom clusters in cancer patients. Cancer Nursing.
  9. Kim H-J , McGuire DB , Tulman L , Barsevick AM . Symptom clusters: Concept analysis and clinical implications for cancer nursing . Cancer Nursing . 2005;28:270–282
  10. Kim J , Mueller CW . Factor analysis: Statistical methods and practical issues . Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications; 1978;
  11. Kim J , Mueller CW . Introduction to factor analysis: What it is and how to do it . Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications; 1978;
  12. Kim YH . Adolescents' stage of change, decision balance, self-efficacy in exercise: Application of transtheoretical model . Korean Journal of Psychology . 2002;13:1–19
  13. Lorr M . Cluster analysis for social scientists . San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 1983;
  14. Miaskowski C , Dodd M , Lee K . Symptom clusters: The new frontier in symptom management research . Journal of the National Cancer Institute Monologues . 2004;32:17–21
  15. Oncology Nursing Society  . Oncology nursing society 2005–2009 research agenda . Retrieved August 28, 2007, from http://www.ons.org/research/information/documents/pdfs/ResearchAgendaExecutiveSummary10-24-07.pdf 2007;
  16. Snook SC , Gorsuch RL . Component analysis versus common factor analysis: A Monte Carlo study . Psychological Bulletin . 1989;106:148–154
  17. Tabachnick BG , Fidell LS . Using multivariate statistics . 4th ed.. New York: HarperCollins College Publisher; 2001;
  18. Tryon RC , Bailey DE . Cluster analysis . New York: McGraw-Hill; 1970;

Back to Article Outline

Bibliography 

  1. Listed articles include those reviewed for this author's previous work on concept analysis (Kim et al., 2005), in which a total of 78 articles were examined. Because random sampling from the database was involved in selecting those articles, the articles fairly well represent the methodology used for symptom cluster research in diverse disciplines. Only those which clearly indicated factor analysis as a method (n=26) are listed here, and articles recently published in oncology are also listed and marked with an asterisk (*).

  2. Abraham G , Nair C , Tracy JI , Simpson GM , Josiassen RC . The effects of clozapine on symptom clusters in treatment-refractory patients . Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology . 1997;17:49–53
  3. Alvir JM , Thys-Jacobs S . Premenstrual and menstrual symptom clusters and response to calcium treatment . Psychopharmacology Bulletin . 1991;27:145–148
  4. Amdur RL , Liberzon I . The structure of posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms in combat veterans: A confirmatory factor analysis of the impact of event scale . Journal of Anxiety Disorders . 2001;15:345–357
  5. Asmundson GJ , Frombach I , McQuaid J , Pedrelli P , Lenox R , Stein MB . Dimensionality of posttraumatic stress symptoms: a confirmatory factor analysis of DSM-IV symptom clusters and other symptom models . Behaviour Research and Therapy . 2000;38:203–214
  6. Barrett B , Locken K , Maberry R , Schwamman J , Brown R , Bobula J , et al.   The Wisconsin Upper Respiratory Symptom Survey (WURSS):A new research instrument for assessing the common cold . Journal of Family Practice . 2002;51:265
  7. Bassett AS , Bury A , Honer WG . Testing Liddle's three-syndrome model in families with schizophrenia . Schizophrenia Research . 1994;12:213–221
  8. Calvaresi E , Bryan J . Symptom experience in Australian men and women in midlife . Maturitas . 2003;44:225–236
  9. *Chen ML , Tseng HC . Symptom clusters in cancer patients . Supportive Care in Cancer . 2006;14:825–830
  10. Clark LA . Toward a consensual set of symptom clusters for assessment of personality disorder . In:  Butcher J ,  Spielberger C editor. Advances in personality assessment . Vol. 8: Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1990;p. 243–266
  11. de Groot CM , Bornstein RA , Baker GB . Obsessive-compulsive symptom clusters and urinary amine correlates in Tourette syndrome . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease . 1995;183:224–230
  12. Dunn RT , Kimbrell TA , Ketter TA , Frye MA , Willis MW , Luckenbaugh DA , et al.   Principal components of the Beck Depression Inventory and regional cerebral metabolism in unipolar and bipolar depression . Biological Psychiatry . 2002;51:387–399
  13. *Gift AG , Jablonski A , Stommel M , Given W . Symptom clusters in elderly patients with lung cancer . Oncology Nursing Forum . 2004;31:203–210
  14. *Gift AG , Stommel M , Jablonski A , Given W . A cluster of symptoms over time in patients with lung cancer . Nursing Research . 2003;52:393–400
  15. Gulick EE . Model confirmation of the MS-related symptom checklist . Nursing Research . 1989;38:147–153
  16. Ho SC , Chan SG , Yip YB , Cheng A , Yi Q , Chan C . Menopausal symptoms and symptom clustering in Chinese women . Maturitas . 1999;33:219–227
  17. Holzemer WL , Henry SB , Nokes KM , Corless IB , Brown MA , Powell-Cope GM , et al.   Validation of the Sign and Symptom Check-list for persons with HIV disease (SSC-HIV) . Journal of Advanced Nursing . 1999;30:1041–1049
  18. Hunter M , Battersby R , Whitehead M . Relationships between psychological symptoms, somatic complaints and menopausal status . Maturitas . 1986;8:217–228
  19. Mitchell ES , Woods NF . Symptom experiences of midlife women: Observations from the Seattle Midlife Women's Health Study . Maturitas . 1996;25:1–10
  20. Rusch KM , Guastello SJ , Mason PT . Differentiating symptom clusters of borderline personality disorder . Journal of Clinical Psychology . 1992;48:730–738
  21. Shiffman SM , Jarvik ME . Smoking withdrawal symptoms in two weeks of abstinence . Psychopharmacology . 1976;50:35–39
  22. Siegel JP , Myers BJ , Dineen MK . Premenstrual tension syndrome symptom clusters: Statistical evaluation of the subsyndromes . Journal of Reproductive Medicine . 1987;32:395–399
  23. Taub E , Cuevas JL , Cook EW , Crowell M , Whitehead WE . Irritable bowel syndrome defined by factor analysis. Gender and race comparisons . Digestive Diseases and Sciences . 1995;40:2647–2655
  24. Westbrook JI , Talley NJ . Empiric clustering of dyspepsia into symptom subgroups: A populationbased study . Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology . 2002;37:917–923
  25. Woods NF , Mitchell ES , Lentz M . Premenstrual symptoms: Delineating symptom clusters . Journal of Women's Health and Gender-Based Medicine . 1999;8:1053–1062
  26. Yardley L , Masson E , Verschuur C , Haacke N , Luxon L . Symptoms, anxiety and handicap in dizzy patients: Development of the vertigo symptom scale . Journal of Psychosomatic Research . 1992;36:731–741
  27. Yasuda N , Mino Y , Koda S , Ohara H . The differential influence of distinct clusters of psychiatric symptoms, as assessed by the general health questionnaire, on cause of death in older persons living in a rural community of Japan . Journal of the American Geriatrics Society . 2002;50:313–320

PII: S1976-1317(08)60025-0

doi:10.1016/S1976-1317(08)60025-0

Asian Nursing Research
Volume 2, Issue 1 , Pages 17-24, March 2008

Article Tools